Latest News

In personal injury cases, many clients are often confused when they find out that their health insurance isn’t covering their medical bills as they would expect. This confusion typically arises due to the legal and financial concepts of liens and subrogation, which play a key role in how medical expenses are handled after an accident. Let’s explore how liens work in these cases and why health insurance coverage might not apply the way clients think it should.

What is a Lien in a Personal Injury Case?

A lien is a legal claim made by a third party (often a healthcare provider, health insurer, or workers' compensation) to be repaid from the settlement or judgment a client receives in a personal injury case. This lien ensures that the party who covered the medical expenses is reimbursed before the injured party sees any of their settlement funds.

Essentially, a lien means that the provider or insurer has a right to some of the compensation you receive for your injury to cover the costs of your medical care. This arrangement exists because these providers or insurers pay for your medical treatment on the assumption that if you win or settle your case, they will get repaid. They must include such language in their health insurance contract and a skilled attorney will always review your health insurance contract to assess the validity of such liens. 

Why Does Health Insurance Not Always Cover Medical Bills?

Many clients expect their health insurance to step in and cover all their medical expenses after an accident, but this is where subrogation comes into play. Subrogation is the legal right of your health insurer to recover the money it spent on your medical bills from any settlement or judgment you receive. Essentially, if your health insurance pays your medical bills, they will likely seek repayment once you receive compensation from the at-fault party’s insurance.

Health insurers often put a lien on your personal injury case to ensure they are reimbursed. This process is not something insurers typically explain in detail to policyholders, which can lead to confusion when clients learn they still owe money after their case is resolved.

Common Misunderstandings About Subrogation

One of the most common questions clients ask is: "Why isn’t my health insurance just covering my medical expenses like usual?" The answer lies in the purpose of subrogation rights, which are part of most health insurance policies. Insurers argue that since the accident was caused by someone else, that party (or their insurance) should ultimately be responsible for the costs of the injured person’s medical care, not the health insurer. This is why they seek reimbursement.

Here’s a breakdown of why this happens:

• Preventing double recovery: If your health insurance covers your bills and you receive compensation from the at-fault party’s insurance for those same bills, you would essentially be "double-dipping" — getting paid twice for the same expenses. Subrogation prevents this by allowing your health insurance to recover the amount they paid.
• Lowering premiums: Insurance companies argue that subrogation helps keep costs down for everyone. If they weren’t allowed to recover money in cases where someone else is responsible for the injury, they’d have to raise premiums to cover the additional costs.

Why Do Liens and Subrogation Exist?

Liens and subrogation are in place to ensure fairness and financial responsibility. If you are injured due to someone else's negligence, the law holds that they (or their insurance) should be responsible for the resulting costs. But in the immediate aftermath of an accident, health insurance often steps in to cover your care so you can focus on recovery. Once you receive compensation for your injury, however, it's only fair (from a legal perspective) that your insurer is reimbursed for the costs they covered upfront.

Conclusion: What Should Clients Know?

Liens and subrogation are important aspects of personal injury cases that many clients aren’t aware of. When a settlement is reached, the funds are not just paid directly to the injured party. Instead, medical liens are typically resolved first, and only after those obligations are satisfied does the client receive the remaining funds.

If you're navigating a personal injury claim, it's essential to understand that your health insurer will likely seek reimbursement from your settlement through a lien. This is why working with a knowledgeable attorney is critical. Your lawyer can negotiate with lienholders to ensure you receive the maximum compensation possible after your medical bills are taken care of.

In summary, liens exist to ensure that medical providers and insurers are reimbursed for the care they provide, while subrogation protects insurers from bearing the financial burden of an injury that wasn’t their fault. Understanding these concepts helps set realistic expectations about the distribution of any compensation you receive.

If you have questions about liens, subrogation, or any aspect of your personal injury case, the team at Harris Personal Injury Lawyers is here to help. Contact us today at 1-800-GO-HARRIS for a free consultation and let us fight to get you the compensation you deserve.